{
  "task_id": "cw_114_task_c",
  "world_id": "world_114_crestline_inventory_unit_economics_and_counterparty_audit",
  "task_name": "World 114 Task C  -  Counterparty Top-Down COGS % of MSRP vs. Retained Pre-Discount MSRP & Physical Unit Bridge (R51 / R58)",
  "prompt": "Using `crestline_inventory_unit_economics_and_counterparty_audit_2026_Q3.xlsx`, reconcile the raw YTD Sep 2026 Shopify gross, returned, virtual, and net physical garment units, and evaluate the counterparty's top-down 16.7% MSRP COGS benchmark against Gross Sales, Retained Pre-Discount MSRP, and bottom-up Total Landed COGS.",
  "context_files": [
    "crestline_inventory_unit_economics_and_counterparty_audit_2026_Q3.xlsx"
  ],
  "rubric": [
    {
      "id": "cw114c_c1",
      "criterion_type": "Reasoning (numerical)",
      "description": "Reconciles raw YTD Sep 2026 Shopify units: 674,897 gross units ordered (620,850 physical garments + 54,047 virtual items) less 92,987 returned units (92,361 returned physical garments = 14.88% return rate) equals 581,910 net items sold (528,493 net physical garments + 53,417 virtual items: 16,666 Swap Protect, 33,900 Digital Style Guides, and 2,851/2,855 Gift Cards)."
    },
    {
      "id": "cw114c_c2",
      "criterion_type": "Reasoning (numerical)",
      "description": "Proves that Baxter's 16.7% COGS rate equals $17.76/u delivered garment cost divided by ~$106.35 full retail MSRP, and that multiplying 16.7% by pre-return Gross Sales ($64,711,606.69 -> $10,806,838.32) overstates COGS by +$1,239,231.95 by charging COGS on 92,361 returned physical garments (-$7,420,550.60 returns)."
    },
    {
      "id": "cw114c_c3",
      "criterion_type": "Reasoning (numerical)",
      "description": "Shows that applying 16.7% to Retained Pre-Discount MSRP ($57,291,056.09 = $64,711,606.69 Gross Sales - $7,420,550.60 Returns) yields $9,567,606.37, reconciling within $31,986.05 (0.3%) of bottom-up Total Landed COGS ($9,535,620.32 = $9,386,035.68 delivered garments + $149,584.64 packaging)."
    },
    {
      "id": "cw114c_c4",
      "criterion_type": "Reasoning (qualitative)",
      "description": "Explains why any COGS % benchmarked against full pre-discount MSRP ($17.76 / $106.35 = 16.7%) must be applied to Retained Pre-Discount MSRP (Gross Sales less Returns) rather than pre-return Gross Sales or post-discount Net Sales ($47,997,651.07)."
    }
  ],
  "metadata": {
    "domain": "Fractional_CFO",
    "category": "Fractional CFO Periodic Inventory Unit-Cost Anchor, VLOOKUP Hygiene & Counterparty MSRP COGS Audit",
    "subcategory": "Prior-Year Periodic Inventory Unit-Cost Anchor (R56), WH2 Check-Series VLOOKUP Hygiene (R57), Retained Pre-Discount MSRP COGS (R58) & Return Disposal Write-Off Parity (R59)",
    "estimated_completion_hours": 3.5
  },
  "license": "Level Personal, Academic & Non-Commercial Evaluation License v1.0 (Commercial Use Requires License from sam@levelcfo.com)",
  "commercial_licensing_contact": "sam@levelcfo.com",
  "canary_watermark_token": "LEVEL-IP-CANARY-9F4A-7C2E-PERSONAL-USE-ONLY-CONTACT-SAM-AT-LEVELCFO-COM"
}