The Level Index, by trade
Mechanical contractor financial benchmarks
Operating benchmarks for commercial mechanical and HVACR contractors: compare your project labor overruns, preventive maintenance contract margins, progress billing speed, and collections against Level's 2,242-contractor dataset alongside public pure-play peers (Comfort Systems, EMCOR, Limbach).
SMB Mechanical Operating Targets & Level Index Snapshot
44.3% Median
Completed-Job Gross Margin
60.2% 75th pct · pooled cross-trade (1,747,089 jobs)
37.9% Median
Preventive Maintenance Gross Margin
53.5% 75th pct · pooled SMBs, $10K+ agreement rev (n=259)
40.0% of Jobs
Jobs Over Labor Budget
Pooled cross-trade SMBs (315,393 budgeted jobs)
1d vs. 7d Lag
Progress vs. End Invoicing
Pooled cross-trade median (n=733 firms)
Proprietary SMB Dataset · 2,242 Contractors Analyzed
The Level Index: Real SMB Contractor Operating Benchmarks
Pooled cross-trade distributions from Level's 2,242-contractor SMB research universe (covering HVAC, plumbing, electrical, mechanical, refrigeration, and fire protection; roofing and general contracting are outside that pool). Metrics use company-level percentiles except completed-job gross margin and labor-budget overruns, which are measured per job, and each metric carries its own eligible sample and observation window.
n=464 SMB contractors. Cash collected divided by billed revenue across the six-trade pool; top decile 96.0%. The benchmark window is not published. Timing, credits and write-offs need separate reconciliation.
n=733 total; post-completion subset count not published · 2022 to 2026 observations. 1 day with progress billing included; 7 days among post-completion invoicers. Subset and bottom-decile populations are not separately counted.
n=794 SMB contractors · 2022 to 2026 observations. On decided quotes; 38.1% across all quotes.
n=1,747,089 jobs / 1,791 companies · 2022 to 2026 observations. Blended across trades. Compare only jobs where revenue and direct costs are assigned to the same job.
The Level lens: where apparent SMB job margin goes
A commercial mechanical contract quoted at 40% margin often lands closer to 22% after unbilled labor burden, coordination time, and receivable financing.
Where a commercial mechanical contract's apparent margin goes (% of revenue)
Source / sample: Illustrative $100 mechanical contract margin bridge
On $100 of contract revenue: start from a 40% quoted gross margin, then account for 9 points of unbilled pipefitter and tech payroll burden, 4 points of unbilled project coordination and drive time, and 5 points of working-capital financing across a 90-to-118-day commercial collection cycle, leaving 22% net contribution. Compute your actual financing drag from your net financed balance, credit line rate, and collection days.
Interactive Matched-Scope Shop Check
Instant self-check · No email requiredCheck your mechanical gross margin & direct labor definition
Commercial mechanical and retrofit contractors run tighter 22-36% gross spreads where unbilled coordination and 60-90+ day retainage drive cash.
Planning band: 22% to 36%
Watch threshold: <= 33% fully burdened
Matched-Scope Read (28% adj.)
Within typical planning range: verify QuickBooks clearing accounts and job-cost reports tie out to $0.00 monthly.
Check your own numbers
See where your mechanical shop sits against these numbers.
Send the number in your P&L, payroll, billing, or job-cost reports that you trust least. Level will benchmark it against mechanical peers and turn the gap into a free audit plan. Your numbers stay private, we never publish or share client data.
In the free audit, we check:
- •where your mechanical job margin and labor share land
- •whether your QuickBooks and field-software numbers match
- •which margin, billing, or callback leak deserves the first fix
We use this to prepare your audit before the call. Your numbers stay private.
Public Filings, BLS Wages & Survey Verification
Scaled Public Comps ($1B+ Commercial Peers) & Government Data
Verifiable SEC 10-K, BLS wage, and CFMA survey anchors. Public enterprise contractors operate on commercial bid mixes and longer institutional billing cycles, so treat them as market verification rather than a $3M to $30M private-shop target.
19-28%
Gross margin
across three selected public contractors with substantial mechanical operations (FY2024-2025)
6-11%
Net margin
Comfort Systems, EMCOR, Limbach (FY2024-2025)
~$324-401K
Revenue / employee
Level calculation from SEC filings, FY2024-2025; employee definitions differ
~90-118 days
DSO
implied from SEC 10-K receivables and revenue
How to read this: Level research pools HVAC, plumbing, electrical, mechanical, refrigeration and fire protection. Roofing and general contracting are outside that pool. The sources below are selected for relevance to mechanical contractors; some are proxies or all-contractor references (SEC filings, BLS, CFMA, industry research), each tagged by confidence tier. Level's research below combines those trades. Each value explains the time period, businesses included and what was measured.
How three large public contractors with substantial mechanical operations compare.
Public mechanical contractor gross margin, FY2024-2025
Source / sample: FY2024-2025 10-Ks (LMB, FIX, EME)
FY2024-2025 public filings show 19-28% gross and 6-11% net margins at large diversified contractors with substantial mechanical operations. Consolidated results include other work. They are comparison points, public enterprise benchmarks rather than a private-shop ceiling; match segment and margin definition first.
Reported margins differ across customer relationships and mixed business segments; the categories do not isolate a cause.
Limbach and EMCOR segment margins (gross vs. operating margin)
Source / sample: Limbach FY2024 (gross margin); EMCOR FY2025 (operating margin)
EMCOR FY2025 operating margins and Limbach FY2024 gross margins compare different definitions. EMCOR Building Services includes both facilities and project/repair work. Limbach ODR groups owner relationships, not exclusively diagnostic service. Compare similar work using the same gross or operating margin definition.
Receivables equal 90 to 118 days of revenue at these public mechanical contractors.
Implied DSO from FY2024-2025 receivables (days)
Source / sample: Computed from SEC 10-K receivables / revenue
Public receivable-to-revenue ratios describe balances, including commercial progress billings and retainage. Financing depends on net working capital: eligible receivables, contract assets and retainage less payables, retainage payable and billings in excess. Calculate net financed balance times annual rate times actual days/365. A high gross receivable ratio does not by itself prove financing loss.
Source: Computed from Comfort Systems, EMCOR, Limbach FY2024-2025 10-Ks
Mechanical benchmarks, by source
5 source-verified rows (Tier A to E)Public mechanical gross margin
Tier A19% to 28%
Comfort Systems 21-24%, EMCOR 19%, Limbach 26-28% (FY2024-2025).
Source: SEC 10-K filings (FIX, EME, LMB)
Public mechanical net margin
Tier A6% to 11%
Comfort Systems 7-11%, EMCOR 6.9% (retained FY2024), Limbach 6.0% (FY2025).
Source: SEC 10-K filings
Revenue per employee
Tier D~$324K to $401K
Comfort Systems ~$401K (FY2025); EMCOR ~$386K and Limbach ~$324K references span FY2024-2025, with individual headcount denominators requiring verification before a current-company comparison.
Source: Computed from SEC 10-K filings
Mechanical DSO (implied)
Tier D~90 to 118 days
EMCOR ~91, Comfort Systems ~103, Limbach ~118, computed from FY2024-2025 receivables. Reflects retainage and progress billing.
Source: Computed from SEC 10-K filings
CFMA specialty-trade net before tax
Tier B6.9% (all-respondent Best in Class reference 11.9%)
Historical 2023 specialty-trade central reference. The 11.9% value describes the all-respondent Best in Class group, top 25% ranked by performance metrics, not a specialty-trade net-margin percentile; these are different populations.
Source: CFMA 2024 Construction Financial Benchmarker (n=1,290)
Tier A = stated public-company SEC or BLS observations; verify the exact period and scope. Tier B = trade-association survey or research-firm report (CFMA, IBISWorld). Tier C = industry publications or planning references, directional only. Tier D = Level calculations from filing inputs. Tier E = Level pooled research. Public-company figures describe large operators, not typical private firms or attainable upper bounds. Where sources conflict, both are shown, never averaged.
What the public mechanical contractors actually earn
These contractors have substantial mechanical operations and different other business lines. FY2024-2025 segment definitions separate customer relationships or business scope; they do not isolate a single service-pricing effect.
| Company / scope | Gross | Operating | Net | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Comfort Systems USA (FIX)Consolidated, FY2025 | 24.1% | 14.4% | ~11.2% | Large public commercial mechanical contractor. |
| EMCOR (EME)US Mechanical Construction segment, FY2025 | n/d | 12.8% | n/d | The mechanical-construction arm. |
| EMCOR (EME)US Building Services segment, FY2025 | n/d | 6.0% | n/d | Mixed facilities, retrofit, controls and repair work; operating margin, not gross margin. |
| Limbach (LMB)ODR vs GCR gross margin, FY2024 | 31.2% / 21.1% | n/d | n/d | Owner-direct vs general-contractor relationships; not service-only. |
EMCOR segment operating margins exclude corporate administration; they are not consolidated operating margins. n/d = not disclosed at that cut. EMCOR FY2025 consolidated operating margin (10.1%) includes an 85 bps one-time UK-ops-sale gain; the reported US segment margins exclude the separately presented sale gain. Limbach discloses gross margin by segment only.
Match the segment before comparing margins
Mechanical has useful public comparables, but consolidated EMCOR and Comfort Systems include electrical and other work. The segment definitions distinguish customer relationships and mixed business lines; use those scopes rather than a mechanical pure-play label.
The public references use different segment definitions. EMCOR reported 6.0% US Building Services and 12.8% US Mechanical Construction operating margin in FY2025. Building Services includes facilities contracts, HVAC retrofits, automation/controls projects and repairs, so it is not a pure recurring-O&M comparison. Limbach reported 31.2% ODR and 21.1% GCR gross margin in FY2024, grouping customer relationships rather than diagnostic service alone. Compare these scopes separately; gross and operating margin cannot be ranked interchangeably.
Read each segment definition, then compare revenue and complete direct cost for equivalent work. Customer relationships and business-segment categories are not interchangeable.
Source: EMCOR FY2025 filing and separately identified FY2024 Limbach comparison
Public-company anchors used
Comfort Systems USA (FIX), EMCOR (EME), Limbach (LMB). These are large, publicly traded operators. Filing observations and Level calculations labeled Tier D are separately scoped reference points, not a stand-in for a typical private mechanical shop, which runs on different economics.
How AI performs on Commercial Mechanical WIP cutoffs, AR delays & cash covenants (LevelBench-100)Why raw AI chatbots miss working-capital cash signs and unbilled WIP, and how Level Playbooks from 2,200+ past experiences prevent bad QuickBooks entries.
Commercial mechanical contractors operate with longer DSO cycles (~90 to 105 days in public SEC filings), progress billing, and multi-trade subcontractors. In LevelBench-100 (v5.0) (58 live AI model and playbook runs across 924 core close checks and 40 downloadable SMB close workbooks), unassisted AI models scored 52.4% to 95.2% and failed on three close controls:
- 13-Week Cash Covenant & QuickBooks Debt Grouping: Starting from $141,580.45 cash and $216,580.45 base ending cash, when a $135,000.00 commercial Accounts Receivable collection slips past week 13, downside ending cash drops to $81,580.45, breaching the $100,000.00 bank line-of-credit covenant floor by $18,419.55. Unassisted models frequently invert working-capital cash signs (-Delta AR, +Delta AP) or miss Current Portion of Term Debt grouped under QuickBooks Other Current Liability.
- Completed-But-Unbilled WIP, Unsigned CRM Options & Subcontractor Proration: Omitting $28,500.00 of completed September field jobs while recognizing unsigned CRM estimate options or $19,000.00 of November customer deposits early, and failing to prorate cross-month subcontractor bills on Monday-to-Friday business days ($3,600.00 September share).
- Missing Check Stubs & Prior-Bookkeeper Manual JEs: Guessing categories on $20,200.00 of unverified paper checks without check images, double-counting Uncategorized Expense rows already adjusted by a prior bookkeeper's manual Journal Entry, and failing to separate $235.00 of Intuit merchant fees from $19,450.00 settlement batches.
AI paired with Level Playbooks (built from 2,200+ past SMB experiences) and operator review reaches 100.0% accuracy and a 0.0% bad book-entry rate, pairing accrual-gap diagnostics with historical QuickBooks subledger cleanup.
Frequently asked questions
It depends on whether you mean gross or net, and on commercial vs residential work. The best hard reference points are public-company actuals: Public mechanical gross margin: 19% to 28%. Comfort Systems 21-24%, EMCOR 19%, Limbach 26-28% (FY2024-2025). This is a scoped reference, not a measured distribution of private mechanical firms.. The retained CFMA 2024 Benchmarker (2023 financials, 1,290 valid financial respondents) reports 6.3% net income before tax for all respondents and 11.9% for its Best in Class group, the top 25% ranked by performance metrics rather than a net-margin percentile. These are historical all-contractor references, not a measured mechanical-only cohort or a current target. Small private shops vary widely, so use the tiered sources on this page rather than a single number.
Named sources selected for relevance to mechanical contractors, including separately labeled proxies and all-contractor references: public-company SEC 10-K filings, BLS wage data, CFMA's Construction Financial Benchmarker, and industry research, each tagged by confidence tier with a source link. Level's pooled research covers HVAC, plumbing, electrical, mechanical, refrigeration and fire protection; it excludes roofing and general contractors. It includes mechanical operators among these segments, but Level does not publish a separately measured mechanical-only cohort. Collection, billing and quote metrics are pooled cross-trade references; the broader 2,200+ research universe is not the contributing sample for each metric.
In LevelBench v5.0 (58 live AI model and playbook runs across 924 core SMB close checks and 40 downloadable client close workbooks, including an $850,000 hospital chiller AIA G702/G703 progress-billing job), unassisted models scored 52.4% to 95.2% and repeatedly missed commercial mechanical close controls: including $34,000.00 of uninstalled warehouse materials inside cost-to-cost WIP progress, booking a $90,000.00 sheetmetal subcontractor bill at the $81,000.00 net check amount (omitting $9,000.00 of 10% retainage), or missing a $100,000.00 debt covenant breach under a $135,000.00 commercial AR collection delay. Pairing AI with Level Playbooks (built from 2,200+ past SMB experiences) and controller review achieves 100.00% accuracy across all 5,923 full-vault checks.
They offer useful, separately scoped public references. Comfort Systems, EMCOR and Limbach include substantial mechanical operations alongside different business mixes. Their retained FY2024-2025 figures (19-28% gross, 6-11% net) are not a measured private-shop distribution or a promised upper bound. Match customer relationship, work type, scale and margin definition before applying a comparison.
Retainage and progress billing affect public-company receivable ratios, but do not explain your own aging. Match the ratio definition, then trace billed, unbilled, disputed and retainage balances. Carrying cost depends on net financed working capital after payables and contract liabilities, not gross receivables alone.
Tier A and B rows name their source and link the record or source index where available. The full tiered dataset for all six trades (public-company actuals, BLS wages, CFMA and market figures, each with its source URL) is downloadable and free to cite with attribution. Download the per-trade benchmark facts (JSON).
See where your mechanical numbers land
We pull your margin, labor economics, and collections and compare your matched-scope figures with public references and the pooled Level Index, with each sample identified, then show you the first leak to fix.
No commitment. Real numbers, not generic advice.